Skincare · reviewed

LANEIGE Lip Sleeping Mask
vs e.l.f. Cosmetics Holy Hydration! Lip Mask

The buying question

How do the listed key actives, disclosed percentages and fragrance listing differ?

Important differences

Same on 1 of 2 features checked

Both are fragranced overnight lip masks, but they share none of their featured ingredients: LANEIGE features berry fruit juices, plant butters, coconut oil and vitamin C, while e.l.f. features hyaluronic acid, squalane and castor seed oil. Per gram, e.l.f. ($8 for 4.4 g) costs more than LANEIGE ($24 for 20 g).

Equivalent performance is not established.

How we reached this verdict ↗

Original

LANEIGE

LANEIGE Lip Sleeping Mask, Berry (Original) — 20 g

$24.00US price

$120.00 / 100 g

Checked Oct 28, 2026, 4:51 PM EDT

Alternative

e.l.f. Cosmetics

e.l.f. Cosmetics Holy Hydration! Lip Mask — 4.4 g

$8.00US price

$181.82 / 100 g

Checked Oct 28, 2026, 4:52 PM EDT

Same, partial, different, unknown.

“Same” means a recorded feature matches, not equivalent performance.

Listed key actives and disclosed percentages

Different

Original: Berry fruit complex: percentage undisclosed; Coconut oil: percentage undisclosed; Shea butter: percentage undisclosed; Murumuru seed butter: percentage undisclosed; Vitamin C (ascorbic acid): percentage undisclosed; Hyaluronic acid (sodium hyaluronate): Absent from full ingredient list (0%); Squalane: Absent from full ingredient list (0%); Castor seed oil: Absent from full ingredient list (0%); Brand-stated
Alternative: Hyaluronic acid (sodium hyaluronate): percentage undisclosed; Squalane: percentage undisclosed; Castor seed oil: percentage undisclosed; Berry fruit complex: Absent from full ingredient list (0%); Coconut oil: Absent from full ingredient list (0%); Shea butter: Absent from full ingredient list (0%); Murumuru seed butter: Absent from full ingredient list (0%); Vitamin C (ascorbic acid): Absent from full ingredient list (0%); Brand-stated

The two share none of their featured ingredients. LANEIGE features a berry fruit complex, coconut oil, shea and murumuru butters and vitamin C; none of these is in e.l.f.'s ingredient list. e.l.f. features hyaluronic acid, squalane and castor seed oil; none of these is in LANEIGE's list. Neither brand states amounts.

Sources

Original: LANEIGE US product page (key ingredients and Berry ingredient list); Checked Oct 28, 2026; LANEIGE's full ingredient list for the Berry (Original) scent (brand page; the same list appears on Sephora) was read: sodium hyaluronate, squalane and Ricinus communis (castor) seed oil are not listed, so they are recorded as 0%. The fruit ingredients in the list are pomegranate, raspberry and grape juices; LANEIGE does not say which entries make up its berry fruit complex. No percentages are stated.
Alternative: e.l.f. Cosmetics US product page (key ingredients and full ingredient list); Checked Oct 28, 2026; e.l.f.'s full ingredient list (brand page) was read: fruit juices or extracts, coconut oil, shea butter, murumuru seed butter and ascorbic acid are not listed, so LANEIGE's featured ingredients are recorded as 0%. e.l.f. states no percentages.

Fragrance listed

Same

Original: Yes; Brand-stated
Alternative: Yes; Brand-stated

Both ingredient lists include Fragrance (Parfum). e.l.f. also lists linalool, geraniol, benzyl benzoate and limonene, and describes a berry flavor and scent.

Sources

Original: LANEIGE Berry ingredient list; Checked Oct 28, 2026
Alternative: e.l.f. ingredient list; Checked Oct 28, 2026

What we couldn’t check

Listed key actives and disclosed percentages. Neither brand discloses ingredient percentages.
Comparative performance. Texture, scent, overnight wear and lip outcomes have not been compared. This page uses LANEIGE's Berry (Original) scent; other LANEIGE scents have slightly different ingredient lists.